Immigration Appeal Division

Has your immigration application to Canada been refused?
Have you been found to be inadmissible?
Bellissimo Immigration Law Group PC can help with appeals of negative decisions!

We represent hundreds of clients with appeals to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD), and prior to the implementation of the new Immigration Appeal Division Rules, Bellissimo Immigration Law Group PC was invited to weigh-in on proposed changes to the IAD Rules. We were glad to see that much of the feedback provided have been reflected in the new IAD Rules which came into effect on 14 January 2023.

The Immigration Appeal Division, one of four divisions of the Immigration and Refugee Board, hears general appeals on issues such as failed sponsorship applications, removal orders and residency obligations.

The process for appeals to the IAD differ depending on the type of decision being appealed.

Sponsorship Appeals

Failed sponsorship applications may be made by the permanent resident or Canadian citizen who supplied the application to sponsor in support of the foreign national’s application for permanent residence. If the application is unsuccessful, the sponsor can appeal the refusal to the IAD, and the Notice of Appeal must be filed to the IAD within 30 days of receipt of the refusal letter. For years the process included an Appeal Record for the case being produced by the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada no later than 120 days from the date requested. However, under the new IAD Rules, this time period has been shortened to 60 days. The Appellant is then required to produce documents in support of their appeal within 60 days after receiving the Appeal Record – a significant change from the previous rules when documents were to be provided to the IAD 20 days before the hearing. We understand this to be a positive change intended to assist IAD with triaging cases and where possible to attempt to resolve them through early resolution mechanisms, for instance, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), which involves an informal meeting of the appellant, the Minister’s Counsel and the Member of the Immigration Appeal Division.  Appellants counsel can also ask for ADR, although generally whether the appeal may be suitable for ADR or not is determined by an Early Resolution Officer of the IAD. If a positive decision is made at ADR, there is no need for a hearing. In all other circumstances, a hearing will be scheduled, which the IAD Member, who is the decision maker, will decide to either allow or dismiss the appeal. If the appeal is allowed, processing of the sponsorship/permanent residence application will be resumed by Immigration, Refugee and Citizenship Canada. 

However, there are some individuals who cannot file an appeal of a refused sponsorship application. This includes sponsors of applications for permanent residence involving persons who are inadmissible to Canada on grounds of security, violation of human or international rights, certain serious criminality, organized criminality or misrepresentation.

Removal order appeals

Persons who have received a removal order and who are permanent residents or permanent resident visa holders may appeal their removal to the Immigration Appeal Division. Convention Refugees or Protected Persons may also seek a removal order appeal. Notice of Appeal must be filed to the IAD within 30 days after receipt of the removal order. The Minister or the Immigration Division must then provide the record within 30 days of a request for same from the Immigration Appeal Division. Again, the IAD may suggest that the appeal proceed by Alternative Dispute Resolution, although this is rare and generally not applicable for removal order appeals, but early resolution mechanisms do exist and at Bellissimo Immigration Law Group PC we examine each case in detail to determine what is the best appellate remedy. Where a hearing is scheduled at the IAD, a decision will be made to either allow or dismiss the appeal. If the appeal is allowed, then the removal order will be cancelled, and the person will be allowed to remain in Canada. If the removal order is stayed, then the removal is temporarily on hold and the person will be allowed to remain in Canada under certain specified conditions for a period of time, and the conditions of stay and its length will be determined by the IAD. The appeal will then be reconsidered at the end of this period of time by the IAD. At that time, the Division may decide to allow the appeal, continue the stay or dismiss the appeal. If the appeal is dismissed, then the person is removable from Canada at any time.

Residency obligation appeals

To maintain their permanent resident status in Canada, permanent residents are required to be physically present in Canada for at least 730 days during any given 5-year period. Where a finding is made that the individual has not met these requirements, their permanent resident card application or an application for a permanent resident travel document or an application to enter Canada as a permanent resident may be refused and/or a departure order may be issued. If the decision is issued in Canada, then the permanent resident will have 30 days to file the appeal to the IAD from the date of the decision/departure order issuance. If the decision is made by an overseas Canadian visa office (i.e. in cases where permanent resident applied for a permanent resident travel document to return to Canada), then the permanent resident has 60 days from the date of the decision to file the appeal.

Following the filing of the notice of appeal, an appeal record will be produced by the Minister within 60 days of the date requested. IAD member may suggest that the appeal be dealt with through alternative dispute resolution. Again, if alternative dispute resolution is successful, then a hearing will not be required. If it is not, then a hearing will be scheduled. There are two possible resolutions that can flow from the hearing of residency obligations appeal: 1) the appeal can be allowed, and permanent resident status will be maintained. If the appellant is not already in Canada when the appeal is allowed, then a travel document will be issued; 2) the appeal can be dismissed, and permanent resident status will be revoked. If the appellant is in Canada, a departure order that converts to a deportation order within thirty days will be issued.

How can Bellissimo Immigration Law Group PC help?

We have significant experience representing clients on appeals to the Immigration Appeal Division for decades. We can assist at all stages, including with preparation of the notice of appeal, the gathering and filing of required evidence, the preparation of submissions, preparation for witness testimony and in providing representation at the hearing itself. Our firm prides itself on the success we have achieved on appeals due to our thorough preparation of appeal files and our in-depth knowledge of the legislation and case law.  Please contact Bellissimo Immigration Law Group PC if you require assistance at the Immigration Appeal Division.

Contact Us

Papers written by Mario D. Bellissimo on the Immigration Appeal Division

Related Frequently Asked Question (FAQ):

Refugee Protection



Do I need to Appeal to IAD or Waive my Right of Appeal?

Q. I have landed in Canada with my family as permanent residents in May 1996, but I had to go back to India with my family in August 1996. In August 2002, I intended to return to Canada and wrote to the Canadian High Commission in India to clarify my status and issue me an Authorization to return. Since I had not received any response and telephonic discussion was not being entertained, I made a new application in December 2002, just for not losing my PR status. Now I received a response to my application for PR made in Dec. 2002 saying that we are still permanent residents who did not comply with the residency obligation and must sign a Consent to Decision of Residence and Waiver of Appeal Rights, to continue my application. Signing this document removes the PR status also waives the right of appeal of the removal of this status. They continue to say that if we believe we are still PRs, then we must apply for a Permanent Resident Travel Document. They gave us 30 days to provide a response. What is your advise in this case, please?

A. This is a frequent question that we receive. When you left Canada, under the old Act and Regulations, you still had to comply with the residency obligation, meaning at that time that you could not be out of Canada for more than 6 months within any 12-month period. Obviously, you did not comply with this requirement. When you applied for a RRP (Returning Resident Permit) in August 2002, the new legislation was in place as of June 2002, and this type of application was no longer available- hence no response from the visa office. At this point in time, as per the visa office’s letter, you must decide whether to apply for a travel document, which will be refused and then challenge the decision in court (IAD) or, just sign the waiver and continue with your new application. Without knowing all the details of your case, I believe it will be very difficult to demonstrate in court that you complied with the residency obligations and win your case. A permanent resident application may be the better option but consult with an immigration lawyer before any decisions.

Permanent Residence



Permanent Resident Application Refused

Q. This is regarding my brother-in-law’s application for permanent residency. He applied by himself and he was refused recently. He married my sister last month and we decided to apply again, but would need some guidance as we do not want him to be refused again. Both my sister and her husband have post-graduate degrees with considerable experience in their area of finance & business administration. I was wondering why he was refused?

A. It is very difficult to say definitively without reviewing the refusal letter. There may be a number of reasons for the refusal: lack of proper documentation, the degree granting schools are not recognized by the local government as an institution that can issue diplomas/ degrees, insufficient work experience, lack of language ability, etc. One other question that I would have is whether your brother-in-law has advised Immigration Canada about his change of status, after marrying your sister. You might want to consult a specialist regarding the possibility of challenging the refusal at the Federal Court of Canada if warranted. As for a new application, applicants must be very careful as the recent changes allow for only 38 eligible occupations for immigration to Canada without a job offer. So consult before applying to avoid another refusal. Also, a lawyer will review other immigration programs that might apply to your brother in law’s case. Good luck!

Important Immigration Court Decisions

Immigration Appeal Division Decisions



Family Class Appeals (IAD)

  1. Canada v. Chen (2014 FC 262)
    Key paragraphs: 20, 21, 22
  2. Aujla v. Canada (2014 FC 134)
    Key paragraph: 15
  3. Jiang v. Canada (2013 FC 413)
    Key paragraphs:11, 13, 14, 20, 23, 24
  4. Habtenkiel v. Canada (2013 FC 397)
    Key paragraphs: 25, 30
  5. Canada v. Mora (2013 FC 332)
    Key paragraphs: 33, 39
  6. Gill v. Canada (2012 FC 1522)
    Key paragraphs: 25, 32, 33
  7. Patel v. Canada (2012 FC 1389)
    Key paragraph: 35
  8. Russom v. Canada (2012 FC 1311)
    Key paragraphs: 24, 25, 26
  9. Abebe v. Canada (2011 FC 341)
    Key paragraphs: 37, 38, 39
  10. Ashraf v. Canada (2011 FC 1383)
    Key paragraphs: 57, 62, 63, 67, 68
Permanent Residency Appeals (IAD)

  1. Tantoush v. Canada (2014 FC 245)
    Key paragraphs: 22, 23, 24, 25
  2. Canada v. Mukerjee  (2012 FC 310)
    Key paragraph: 7
  3. Bosompem v. Canada (2012 FC 196)
    Key paragraphs: 28, 35, 37, 38
  4. Hillary v. Canada (2011 FCA 51)
    Key Paragraphs: 44, 49, 50

What Our Clients Are Saying
Daniel ColganDaniel Colgan ★★★★★ Extremely well prepared for our consult having read the material and questions I had provided. Provided clear sound advice that I felt very confident in. Thanks.Aleksandra DAleksandra D ★★★★★ They are knowledgeable, provide options and genuinely care about their clients. Highly recommend their services. They have been wonderful.Joanna KrasnodębskaJoanna Krasnodębska ★★★★★ We would like to thank you very much for your professional service, understanding and commitment to our case. Thank you also for taking on this difficult task. Only thanks to your hard work we managed to start a new life in Kanda. We know that our case was not easy, so we are even more glad that you were able to help us. We would like to thank the entire team dealing with our case for giving our daughters a better start in adult life and giving us peace of mind about their future.I will call you with all my heart and full responsibility and I can recommend the Bellissimo Law Firm. Full professionalism and involvement in the matter.Malavika RajasekharanMalavika Rajasekharan ★★★★★ My experience with Bellissimo and their team that assisted with my judicial review process and study permit re-application process were nothing short of exceptional. They conducted themselves with the utmost professionalism, they were very very thorough, extremely detail oriented, very prompt with their fillings and always provided answers to all my questions at all stages of case process ( I asked a lot of questions!!).I am finally here in Canada, as an international student after two rejections all credits to Bellissimo and their team. I want to give special thanks to Amanda D'Angelo, Alexandra Goncharova, Michelle Boeriu, Athena Portokalidis, and Mario Bellissimo - I can't thank you enough for everything you've done for me during the litigation process.I would highly recommend Bellissimo to anyone that wants to retain a team that can get you the results you desire.Hasib VaiHasib Vai ★★★★★ It has been a great journey with Bellissimo Law Group PC! Previously, we filed our SOWP & SP through another regulated ircc consultant and got our applications denied. Our case was very critical with our applications being refused twice. We were terrified as my wife was at Canada completing her studies but our daughter and I were stuck back at home country. Luckily we came through this firm and we directly consulted Mr. Mario D Bellissimo. Honestly he is very professional and a knowledgeable lawyer, he didn't straight away advise to apply but rather focused on the risks involved and the long term consequences. Later with his advice, we applied right after my wife received her work permit. Our file was handed to Ms. Lijing Cao who is a passionate lawyer and undoubtedly expert in immigration laws. She has a great team along with Ms. Shuai Dong who was very dedicated, responsive and cooperative in every step. We got our applications approved this Dec, 2023 and flying for Toronto this Jan, 2024. We are very happy as we got a chance to reunite as a family after a long time. And my deepest respect towards the law firm as a whole. I would definitely recommend this law firm to anybody going through immigration difficulties as I believe by now that each file is taken care in the most dedicated fashion. Special thanks to Mr.Bellissimo, Ms.Lijing and Ms.Shuai to make this possible. It was a big one for us!!Raha SalarzaieRaha Salarzaie ★★★★★ Thanks to the amazing work of BLG, our family is reunited. They have a very professional and trustworthy team that work on a timely manner. They are responsive and work thoroughly on your application, covering every nook and cranny as not to leave a single detail behind. Of course we had our stresses when submitting the application, considering the final decision maker is someone else, but we had peace of mind that we had prepared a perfect application. We will definitely choose BLG again for future applications.Dorma WDorma W ★★★★★ The Bellissimo Law Group is the absolute best!My experience with this law firm has been nothing short of extraordinary. Facing my complex case, their meticulous and thorough approach shone brightly from the very outset.They conducted a thorough interview with us, delving deep into the intricacies of my situation in order to understand fully what it would take to handle my case.Despite the complexity, their expertise turned challenges into opportunities, resulting in a successful outcome.What truly sets the Bellissimo Law Group apart is their commitment to their client. I especially admired how they meticulously instructed me on all necessary forms and information submissions, ensuring I was well-prepared at every stage.The professionalism exhibited by the entire Bellissimo Law Group is also commendable. Their consistent communication and transparent updates provided reassurance for me throughout the journey of my Permanent Residency (PR) application.In conclusion, I wholeheartedly would recommend Bellissimo Law Group for anyone seeking legal immigration representation. Their expertise, dedication, and client-centric approach make them a standout choice for navigating the complexities of any case.Thank you, Bellissimo Law Group, for your unwavering support and outstanding service, you are truly one of a kind!Jagjeet SinghJagjeet Singh ★★★★★ I want to express sincere gratitude to Mr. Belissimo, Ms. Keeley, and the entire Belissimo Law Group team for their invaluable support during the challenging process of obtaining our permanent residency. Our case was particularly complex, receiving a procedural fairness letter from CIC with only one chance to reply. The dedication, hard work, and professional expertise demonstrated by Mr. Belissimo and the team are truly commendable. Their professionalism and intelligence as lawyers shine through, successfully navigating our tough case to secure our permanent residency. I highly recommend them as the top experts in this field. Thank you once again for the immense help and support.Jagjeet.Kuljeet KaurKuljeet Kaur ★★★★★ We are immensely grateful for the exceptional legal support provided by Bellissimo Law Group throughout the challenging process of overcoming medical inadmissibility and securing permanent residence. Bellissimo Law Group demonstrated an unparalleled level of expertise, compassion, and dedication that significantly exceeded my expectations. When we received PFL( Procedural fairness letter) it created a sense of uncertainty and stress for my permanent residence application. Bellissimo Law Group approached the situation with genuine understanding and empathy. Lawyers provided us with clear explanation, addressed all our concerns, and guided us through each step of the process. Mr.Bellissimo and their team went above and beyond to gather necessary medical documentation, collaborated with healthcare professionals, and presented a compelling case that ultimately led to the approval of our permanent residence.We wholeheartedly recommend BellissimoLaw Group to anyone facing medicalinadmissibility issues or navigating thecomplex path to permanent residence.